Millspread · Margin Leak ReportPrivate · Prepared for Acme Steel
Margin Leak Report

Acme Steel

29,796 quote lines from 2025-11-03 to 2026-10-30 (11.9 months; figures annualized ×1.01). 0 rows dropped as unparseable. Replacement cost: index-adjusted (FRED producer price indexes).
Recoverable gross profit / yr
$492K
1.20 margin points on won revenue
Won revenue / yr
$41.10M
Margin on replacement cost
13.4%
Quote win rate
44%

What we found

Your win curve

Win rate by margin on replacement cost, across all quotes. Every point of margin costs some win rate; the highlighted band earns the most gross profit per quote.

70.1%<5%61.3%5–10%50.7%10–15%41.6%15–20%34.1%20–25%24.3%25–30%20.1%30%+

Where the money is

Segments ranked by recoverable gross profit. "Best margin" is the margin that maximizes expected gross profit given your own win curve.

SegmentLines quotedWin rateMedian won marginBest marginUnderpriced winsOverpriced lossesTotal / yr
aluminum · 1–5K lb · tier A1,11246%11.9%15.3%$40K$20K$59K
aluminum · 5–15K lb · tier A32043%8.8%13.4%$43K$4K$48K
carbon · 1–5K lb · tier A5,32745%13.3%16.0%$37K$10K$47K
carbon · 5–15K lb · tier A1,51537%10.4%14.4%$30K$4K$34K
stainless · 1–5K lb · tier A1,08543%14.7%16.0%$14K$9K$23K
aluminum · 1–5K lb · tier C50043%16.4%18.8%$14K$9K$23K
carbon · 15K+ lb · tier A29145%6.8%14.3%$23K$-40$23K
carbon · 1–5K lb · tier B3,07441%16.4%19.5%$18K$4K$22K
aluminum · 1–5K lb · tier B62741%15.3%21.3%$19K$2K$22K
carbon · 5–15K lb · tier B92735%12.7%15.1%$13K$7K$19K

Pricing by salesperson

Margin on won quotes compared with the median for the same metal, order size and customer tier. Negative means the rep prices below what the market is accepting from others.

SalespersonWon revenue / yrWin rateMargin vs. segmentLeft on table / yr
Rep D$4.46M61%-5.9 pts$139K
Rep G$4.55M61%-5.1 pts$110K
Rep C$3.69M47%+0.1 pts$24K
Rep K$3.64M46%-0.2 pts$23K
Rep A$3.16M43%+0.7 pts$19K
Rep E$3.56M45%+0.8 pts$19K
Rep J$3.37M45%+0.9 pts$18K
Rep H$2.46M34%+0.7 pts$16K
Rep L$3.53M41%+1.9 pts$12K
Rep B$3.06M38%+2.0 pts$8K
Rep F$2.87M35%+2.8 pts$4K
Rep I$2.73M29%+5.6 pts$956

Customers priced below their tier

Accounts whose won quotes average at least 4 points under the segment median, usually legacy pricing nobody revisited.

CustomerTierWon linesWon revenue / yrMargin vs. segmentLeft on table / yr
C-0260B52$103K-4.6 pts$3K
C-0623B42$106K-6.0 pts$2K
C-0454C11$42K-7.9 pts$1K
C-0615C10$74K-4.6 pts$995
C-0594C11$17K-5.3 pts$988
C-0349C10$44K-6.1 pts$959
C-0068C12$19K-7.1 pts$941
C-0131B15$52K-4.3 pts$898
C-0553C10$45K-5.2 pts$886
C-0452C19$70K-4.3 pts$725
C-0031C18$41K-5.9 pts$702
C-0334C10$43K-4.7 pts$521

Speed to quote

Win rate by time from request received to quote sent.

48.2%< 1 hr45.9%1–4 hrs39.2%4–24 hrs12.3%> 24 hrs

Lines answered in under an hour won 48% of the time vs. 12% for those taking over a day.

Largest single underpriced wins

QuoteDateCustomerProductLbsPrice / cwtMarginSupported marginLeft on table
Q-1088132026-05-26C-0380aluminum bar12,668$282.681.2%13.6%$2K
Q-1153032026-04-13C-0230aluminum extrusion9,411$297.11-2.2%8.8%$2K
Q-1074812026-04-15C-0459aluminum bar7,109$251.86-4.9%8.8%$2K
Q-1102772026-04-22C-0075aluminum extrusion13,666$299.061.6%8.8%$1K
Q-1033722026-10-07C-0148carbon tube25,809$74.18-4.3%6.8%$1K
Q-1045462026-03-13C-0462aluminum bar9,101$261.420.6%11.9%$1K
Q-1024032026-07-20C-0566aluminum extrusion10,960$311.261.8%8.8%$1K
Q-1082492026-05-15C-0459aluminum extrusion6,510$316.09-0.6%8.8%$1K
Q-1105742026-02-19C-0170aluminum extrusion5,671$282.79-2.2%8.8%$1K
Q-1154722026-02-11C-0075aluminum extrusion5,464$275.42-2.6%8.8%$1K
Q-1168022026-04-16C-0532aluminum plate9,113$266.200.5%8.8%$1K
Q-1162082026-06-25C-0158aluminum sheet6,865$245.40-1.7%8.8%$993

What this data can't see

How this was calculated